Well, that didn’t last long.
A couple of weeks ago I wrote about finally finishing Fantasy Life i and moving on to Donkey Kong Bananza. I had only played for about an hour at the time, so I wasn’t ready to say much beyond the fact that I was enjoying it.
I’ve played more since then, and I still don’t really have anything bad to say about it.
I also don’t particularly want to play it right now.
Maybe I’ll come back to Bananza in a few months and wonder why I ever stopped. I hope I do. But I’ve never really liked the idea that starting a game means I’ve entered into some kind of legally binding agreement to finish it. If I’m sitting down at the end of the day with a couple of hours to play something and repeatedly choosing not to play a particular game, I’m probably trying to tell myself something.
Apparently, what I’m trying to tell myself right now is that I want something cozy.
Maybe it’s because I’m already getting into my fall mood. Maybe it’s because I just spent well over a hundred hours with Fantasy Life i. Whatever the reason, instead of a big new adventure, I’ve been craving something comfortable. Something I can settle into.
That left me considering two obvious choices: Animal Crossing: New Horizons and Stardew Valley.
If you know me, Animal Crossing should win this fight pretty easily.
I absolutely love Animal Crossing. I’ve played every entry in the series since the GameCube. I have Animal Crossing merch scattered around, and I’ve even bought Japanese copies of some of the games just because I wanted them sitting on my shelf.
And then there’s New Horizons.
Like a lot of people, I played an enormous amount of it during the COVID lockdown. At a time when the real world suddenly became very small, my little island gave me somewhere else to go every day. I spent hundreds of hours there, and I don’t think it’s an exaggeration to say that game helped get me through a very strange period of my life.
Animal Crossing isn’t just one of my favorite cozy games. It’s one of my favorite game series, period.
So naturally, I restarted Stardew Valley.
The deciding factor was simple.
I’ve played Stardew before, and I loved it. I love the farming, the town, the characters, fishing, mining and the little routines. But for whatever reason, I never dug into it nearly as deeply as I did New Horizons. There are entire parts of Stardew I barely explored and things I know exist but never really experienced.
That’s what tipped the scales.
I realized I didn’t want something completely new, but I didn’t want something completely familiar either. I wanted a familiar place with unexplored corners.
Starting a new Animal Crossing island would certainly be comforting. I’d enjoy meeting the villagers again, slowly building up the island and inevitably spending far too much time deciding where a virtual park bench should go. But I’ve already spent hundreds of hours discovering what New Horizons has to offer. Right now, going back would mostly be about revisiting something I already love.
Stardew gives me something slightly different.
I know I like it there. I know how the basic rhythms work. I can plant some crops, go fishing, wander into town, poke around the mines and somehow exhaust myself by noon because I watered twelve vegetables.
But I don’t know everything that’s waiting for me.
There’s still that little element of discovery mixed in with all the comfort, and apparently that’s exactly the combination I’m looking for right now.
I’m also perfectly content to leave Animal Crossing alone for a while. At some point Nintendo will announce the next installment, and I already know I’ll be there. I don’t need to manufacture a reason to go back to New Horizons while I wait. I have a ridiculous number of wonderful memories from that island, and I’m happy to leave them there.
As for Donkey Kong Bananza, I’m not declaring that one finished either. It’s just going back on the shelf for now. Maybe someday I’ll be in exactly the mood for what it offers.
Right now, though, I want something slower. Something comfortable. Something I already know I enjoy, but that can still surprise me.
So I started a new farm.
I already know I like it there.
I just don’t know everything that’s waiting for me yet.





